A synopsis of Lebensohl, by Brad Bart.
All alertable bids are marked with a *.
Brad Bart's Synopsis of Lebensohl
Lebensohl over 1NT
More and more players are bidding over your strong 1NT
openings more agressively than in the past.
Lebensohl is a convention which was developed to deal with
interference over your opening bids of 1NT.
In all cases, it is assumed that your partnership
opens a strong 1NT, that is 15-17 HCP.
Let us suppose that your partner opens 1NT and RHO
overcalls 2 (natural).
Without playing Lebensohl, these are the bidding tools
that you have at your disposal.
- 1NT(2)-Double
Penalty.
- 1NT(2)-2
To play. Remember that transfers
are off over interference.
- 1NT(2)-3 or
1NT(2)-3 or
1NT(2)-3
Natural and game-forcing.
- 1NT(2)-3*
The Q-bid is game-forcing Stayman. Opener
will rebid 3NT without a holding of 4 or more spades.
- 1NT(2)-3NT
Natural and game-forcing.
- 1NT(2)-2NT
Natural and invitational.
But there appears to be a problem in this whole structure.
When would you ever want to bid 2NT over their
2?
Presumably, you would need at least one sound heart stopper
and some values to bid 2NT.
There is an alternate bid available when holding this hand: it is Double.
Once you realize that a natural 2NT can never exist, you are half-way
towards understanding Lebensohl.
Instead, we use a bid of 2NT to describe hands which cannot be
handled by the above structure. Don't you wish you had a way
of competing in a suit below the rank of the overcalled suit?
How about some natural invitational bids? Welcome to the
fruits of Lebensohl.
Here is the new structure:
- 1NT(2)-Double
Penalty (no change).
- 1NT(2)-2
To play (no change).
- 1NT(2)-3 or
1NT(2)-3 or
1NT(2)-3
Natural and game-forcing (no change).
- 1NT(2)-3*
The Q-bid is game-forcing Stayman (no change), but this sequence tends to deny a stopper in the
enemy suit (see below).
- 1NT(2)-3NT*
Natural and game-forcing
(no change), but this sequence tends to deny a stopper in the
enemy suit (see below).
- 1NT(2)-2NT*
Lebensohl. Opener is forced to
bid 3 and then responder will describe his hand
further.
- 1NT(2)-2NT*-3*-Pass or
1NT(2)-2NT*-3*-3
To play. Any bid after the Lebensohl relay below 3 of the overcalled suit is signoff.
- 1NT(2)-2NT*-3*-3*
Natural and invitational. Any bid after the Lebensohl relay above 3 of the overcalled suit is invitational. Why? Because we already have shown two sequences to describe a game-forcing hand with spades and a signoff hand
with spades. There aren't any other possibilities.
- 1NT(2)-2NT*-3*-3* or
1NT(2)-2NT*-3*-3NT*
What do you think these sequences should show?
The standard agreement is that the slow Q-bid is still game-forcing Stayman
and that the slow 3NT is still natural and game-forcing. The main difference
is that this sequence shows a stopper in the opponent's overcalled suit.
(Hence the mnemonic "slow shows.")
You can generalize this structure for interference over any natural
overcall at the two level. The only thing that you must keep in
mind are the suits which are above and below the enemy suit so that
you can distinguish an invitational sequence from a signoff sequence.
Notes
- Craig Barkhouse once suggested to me that the invitational
and game-forcing responses should be switched and I think
that's a good idea. The theory is that (on average) you will
hold more game-invitational hands than game-forcing hands
when you play 15-17 notrumps. More utility translates into
better scores.
Unfortunately, the down-side is that when you do hold a
game-forcing hand, your side will often be guessing which game
should be played.
- A lot of people play Lebensohl over a 2
overcall. The obvious disadvantage is that you can't slow-show
a stopper and bid game-forcing Stayman by using Lebensohl.
The other (and perhaps greater) disadvantage is that you lose
all of your notrump structure by playing Lebensohl over
2.
Bridge theorists agree that sequences starting with an
opening bid of 1NT are the best to have. The opener has
described their hand very accurately and the responder has
a lot of control in placing the final contract because so
much structure already exists. They can use Stayman,
Jacoby transfers, Texas transfers, minor suit Stayman,
and fragment bids to name a few. Why give up on your
whole system for something worse? If you do, then I
promise to overcall 2 against
you every time you sit as my right-hand opponent. Promise.
My personal preference is to play that a Double of the
2 overcall is Stayman and the
rest of my system is on. This way is better than submitting
to the damage that the overcall was attempting to do.
Lebensohl over Reverses
A reverse occurs when opener and responder make three bids in three
different suits- the first two bids are at the one level and the
third is a non-jump bid at the two level of a suit of higher rank
than the opener's first bid suit.
Because reverses are forcing to the 3-level, opener should have
a king more than opening values (i.e. 16+) to reverse. If opener
has a bare 16-17 (i.e. not enough to force to game opposite a
minimal response), then responder should have the means to
apply the brakes if they also have a minimal response.
The reverse auctions are:
In standard systems, responder's rebid of the fourth suit is
natural and game-forcing. In order to apply the brakes,
responder rebids his suit or 2NT. When playing Lebensohl over
reverses, this doesn't change, however, 2NT is now Lebensohl
and can never be passed.
In the following sequences, we will examine the first of the
listed reverse auctions: 1-1-2.
- 1-1-2-3 or
1-1-2-3 or
1-1-2-3 or
1-1-2-3 or
1-1-2-3NT
Natural and game-forcing (same as standard).
- 1-1-2-2
Natural and nonforcing (same as standard).
- 1-1-2-2NT*
Lebensohl. This bid is forcing.
- 1-1-2-2NT*-3*
The completion of the relay to 3
shows a minimal reverse. Responder now completes the relay sequence
in a similar manner to Lebensohl over 1NT.
- 1-1-2-2NT*-3*-Pass or
1-1-2-2NT*-3*-3* or
1-1-2-2NT*-3*-3*
Just like in Lebensohl over 1NT, these bids are all signoffs.
- 1-1-2-2NT*-3*-3* or
1-1-2-2NT*-3*-3NT*
What do you think responder was up to? He showed a weak hand and got a
weak response from opener and then did something impossible. Responder
must have a slam-try opposite a minimal reverse.
- 1-1-2-2NT*-3* or
1-1-2-2NT*-3* or
1-1-2-2NT*-3* or
1-1-2-2NT*-3NT* or
1-1-2-2NT*-4*
But what if opener has a game-forcing hand? He hardly wants to
be passed out in 3 when he holds the values for game.
The solution is to bid something other than 3.
Lebensohl in Response to Takeout Doubles
Lebensohl can be used in other bidding situations. The most
common of these is over a weak-two by the opponents.
- (2)-Double-2*
To play. Definitely not a hand to be proud of.
- (2)-Double-2NT*-3*-Pass or
(2)-Double-2NT*-3*-3* or
(2)-Double-2NT*-3*-3*
To play. Again, not a hand to write home about.
Just like using Lebensohl over reverses, the doubler can bid something
other than 3 to show a good hand.
- (2)-Double-3* or
(2)-Double-3* or
(2)-Double-3*
Definitely shows some competitive values. If I had to assign a
number, I would guess around 8 or 9.
Just like using Lebensohl over reverses, if responder uses Lebensohl
as a relay and follows up with 3, then this
should be a try for slam.
The other sequences are the same as described above.
There are two other auctions where I typically play Lebensohl.
- (1)-Double(2)-?
Whenever the opponents bid and raise a suit through partner's
takeout double, 2NT is never natural. It can only be Lebensohl.
- (1)-Double(2*)-?
If the opponents are playing weak jump shifts, then Lebensohl is
almost a requirement to get back the room you've already lost
by their ferocious bidding.
Originally written by Brad Bart on September 22, 1998.