Finally, Lefty Has Guessed Wrong!


PARD (dummy)
S -
H K J
D -
C Q 8 6
ME
S K 10
H 8
D 10
C 10

Accounting time. Lefty started with 4 spades, 1 club, at least 5 diamonds and at least Qxx of hearts. That's at least 13 cards again, so her hand must be:

S Q 9 4 2
H Q 6 2
D A K Q ? x
C 7

But where's the DJ? There can only be two possible explanations.

  1. She didn't have it and didn't realize her partner had it, so she didn't try to cash it.

  2. She had it, but was afraid I would ruff the fourth diamond, pull her last trump and then claim. Her plan would then be to endplay dummy into eventually letting her score a trump promotion with her remaining SQ. If my hand were, say:

    S K 10 x x  H x x x  D x x x  C A x x

    then her play would have been right, even if she held the DJ.
This is all academic, however. I implulsively play the HJ, which holds. Lefty has given me a chance to make 3S, and I wonder if there is any way to maneuver both of:
  1. Pulling the last trump.
  2. Avoiding a diamond loser.
PARD (dummy)
S -
H K
D -
C Q 8 6
LEFTY
S Q
H Q
D ? x
C -
RIGHTY
S -
H 5
D ?
C J 9
ME
S K 10
H -
D 10
C 10

I could try the HK and pitch a diamond, but the followup club head will promote lefty's SQ. Where else could the diamond loser go, though? Fortunately, there is a chance to shed of this loser if righty holds the DJ. Since this is my only possible line to gain a trick, I'm going to take it.

I lead the HK from dummy and ruff(!) with the S10. Now I cash the SK, pulling lefty's last trump and I have caught righty in a backward squeeze! He resigns by pitching the C9, which makes dummy good. Making 3S was worth 100% of the matchpoints (not to mention bragging rights). I couldn't have asked for friendlier opponents than these to enjoy the remainder of the matchpoints.


Further Analysis

There are a few more points that I'd like to make.

  1. A more technically correct play at trick 9 would have been the HK instead of the HJ, just in case righty was playing with me. I could have blown my chance in the end position by this impulsive play.
  2. My other impulsive play of the CK certainly should have cost, but it didn't. This was a simple case of failure to count the hand.
  3. Some might have planned to make a safety play in the trump suit had righty followed to the second round. The standard trump safety play with SAxxx opposite SK10xx is to first play the SA and then lead towards the remaining SK10x, playing the S10 if second hand plays low. It is important to note that this would not have been correct on this hand. Suppose righty played low to the second round of spades and lefty won the S10 with the SJ. Another high diamond would again endplay dummy, still with 2 diamond losers in hand and a high trump out. The safety play would have been correct if there was still an entry to declarer's hand.
  4. Cashing the SAK was a matchpoint play to get all of our deserved uptricks. At IMPS, a more secure route to 9 tricks would be to win the SJ in hand with the SK and try to ruff out as many diamonds as possible.
  5. I don't know what went wrong in the diamond suit for the defenders. The standard signal on the first round of a side suit when there is visible shortness in dummy is suit­preference. On further rounds of the suit, they tend to show remainder count. Perhaps, if they were using remainder count after the first round of the suit, lefty would have figured things out.

The Fallible Genius - a chronicle by Brad Bart
January 18, 1998